Request for game suggestions. 3 friends, no clue what to play anymore.

Hey there,

we are 3 guys(~20yr) who are gaming alot together and naturally have gone through a lot of games. Recently we can't really get a hold of a nice game to play. I'd like to know what you guys play in your group of friends and what keeps you entertained.

We are mostly aiming at some game we can play for a longer time or something which doesnt get old too fast. We prefer games which don't require monthly subscription or some kind of pay2win feature so we have some feel of competing against others/against each other, or have fun playing casual stuff together. They don't need to be AAA titles, Indie/f2p games are welcome, too.

I'll make a list of games we played alot and gradually. Same genres are fine if it's something fresh and new :)

Some Info:

Game which are local only are cool, too. (hamachi)

We are thinking about maybe playing PUBG and/or Destiny 2 in the near future.

Currently playing Wotlk WoW and League from time to time.

 Steam Games: 

• Age of Empires 2/3

• Various Anno

• Borderlands

• CoD MW3

• Company of Heroes 2

• Counter Strike GO

• The Culling

• Dungeon of the Endless

• Endless Legend(Space)

• Factorio

• Killing Floor/ Left for Dead / Warhammer End Times - Vermintide

• Magicite

• MK X (prolly no other fighting games in the futute)

• Offworld Trading Company

• Pixel Privateers

• Rocket League

• Rust

• Civilization 5/6

• Starbound

• Tabletop Simulator (Suggest games you play, we have 300 hours on there, played most popular games, + many more we could find. Still looking for more)

• Terraria (each big patch + mods sometimes)

 Other Games: 

• Diablo 2

• Starcraft 2

• Battlefield 3

• Various Command and Conquer

• League of Legends

• Dota 2

• Paragon

• Smite

• Wow

• Blade and Soul (and various other f2p MMO's)

Thank you for suggestions, we are really desperate, just one new cool game suggested would be awesome and bring some fresh air into our gaming experience :)