What is the best farm layout? I dont think the pinwheel is the best here is why:

These are the 2 best layouts for farms:

The pinwheel:

https://i.imgur.com/5BjfuWA.png

https://imgur.com/0PfhHab

And the square:

https://i.redd.it/fsmrlh4xzad01.png

Most argue that the pinwheel is the best and most efficient.

But I think the best is the square because efficiency is not all.

And here are my reasons:

The pinwheel needs a very clean land. It is hard to do and get it right.

The square one is more intuitive and makes more uniform use of space.

The pinwheel will leave the land with an irregular design which is innefficient to place defenses and buildings. And space is important.

I dont know how much difference and how much more food the pinwheel provides. But i tried making 4 pinwheel with 8 farms each and its a mess.

The square one leaves the space more clean and better to be used by other buildings.

It is also better for adding new modules of farms without making errors and actual inefficient farms trying to do a perfect pinwheel. Time and space is more important than having the villagers closer to the mill. Plus it seems quite the same.

Tell me what you think, and why im wrong if im wrong.